A Bill for an Act
Page 1, Line 101Concerning modifying certain tax expenditures.
Bill Summary
(Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov.)
Section 2 of the bill creates a new tax credit. The new tax credit allows taxpayers to claim a refundable tax credit, in addition to the child tax credit and the family affordability tax credit, in an amount determined by the amount and age of the taxpayer's children and the taxpayer's income. The total amount of the new tax credit is adjusted annually based on legislative council staff projections, such that the total amount of the new tax credit claimed in an income tax year is projected to be the same as the amount of revenue raised in sections 3 and 4.
Beginning January 1, 2027, the bill also repeals the downloaded software sales and use tax exemption so that all software that is available for repeated sale and license qualifies as tangible property and thus is subject to sales and use tax. The bill exempts from sales and use tax downloaded software governed by a negotiable license agreement or developed for use by a particular user.
Page 2, Line 1Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:
Page 2, Line 2SECTION 1. Legislative declaration.
Page 2, Line 3(1) The general assembly finds and declares that:
Page 2, Line 4(a) The general assembly has an ongoing responsibility to review,
Page 2, Line 5evaluate, and update the state tax code within constitutional limitations
Page 2, Line 6to ensure that the state code is effective, equitable, and aligned with
Page 2, Line 7Colorado's priorities;
Page 2, Line 8(b) (I) The downloaded software sales and use tax exemption
Page 2, Line 9exempts certain software that is downloaded at the time of purchase from
Page 2, Line 10sales and use tax by modifying the definition of tangible personal
Page 2, Line 11property to not include certain types of software;
Page 2, Line 12(II) Unlike Colorado, thirty-four states subject the sale and use of
Page 2, Line 13downloadable software to state sales and use tax;
Page 2, Line 14(III) At the local level in Colorado, unlike the state level, many
Page 2, Line 15home rule municipalities subject the sale and use of downloadable
Page 2, Line 16software to a local sales and use tax. Therefore, the sales and use tax
Page 2, Line 17treatment of the sale and use of downloadable software is not consistent
Page 2, Line 18across the state.
Page 2, Line 19(IV) The primary purpose of the downloaded software sales and
Page 2, Line 20use tax exemption tax expenditure was to resolve taxpayer confusion and
Page 2, Line 21decrease administrative burden by clarifying the definition of tangible
Page 2, Line 22personal property as it relates to software; and
Page 3, Line 1(V) The primary purpose of modifying the downloaded software
Page 3, Line 2sales and use tax exemption tax expenditure is to further resolve taxpayer
Page 3, Line 3confusion and decrease administrative burden by clarifying that all
Page 3, Line 4computer software available for repeated sale and governed by a
Page 3, Line 5nonnegotiable license agreement qualifies as tangible personal property
Page 3, Line 6and is subject to sales and use tax;
Page 3, Line 7(c) (I) Colorado state income tax is determined based on the
Page 3, Line 8amount of a person's federal taxable income;
Page 3, Line 9(II) Recent federal law modified the computation of federal
Page 3, Line 10taxable income and so impacted Colorado state income tax revenue;
Page 3, Line 11(III) The recent federal modification to the computation of federal
Page 3, Line 12taxable income reduced state income tax revenue;
Page 3, Line 13(IV) The amount and availability of the family affordability tax
Page 3, Line 14credit is determined in part by the amount of state income tax revenue;
Page 3, Line 15(V) Therefore, by modifying the computation of federal taxable
Page 3, Line 16income, federal law impacted the amount and availability of the family
Page 3, Line 17affordability tax credit; and
Page 3, Line 18(VI) At least in part due to the enactment of recent federal law, the
Page 3, Line 19family affordability tax credit will not be available for the 2026 state
Page 3, Line 20income tax year and will be available in a reduced amount for income tax
Page 3, Line 21years 2027 and 2028;
Page 3, Line 22(d) (I) In establishing the family affordability tax credit, the
Page 3, Line 23general assembly found and declared that:
Page 3, Line 24(A) Colorado families struggle to afford many necessary goods
Page 3, Line 25and services, such as child care, housing, and health care. Eighty-three
Page 3, Line 26percent of Colorado parents worry that their children won't be able to
Page 3, Line 27afford to live in the state in the future.
Page 4, Line 1(B) Targeted tax credits are a proven tool to lift families out of
Page 4, Line 2poverty. Research has shown that families that claim these types of tax
Page 4, Line 3credits, such as the state and federal child tax credit and the state and
Page 4, Line 4federal earned income tax credit, have better health, improved schooling
Page 4, Line 5outcomes, and increased adult earning potential. As the cost of raising
Page 4, Line 6children has increased, a family affordability tax credit is critical for the
Page 4, Line 7well-being of many children and families across Colorado.
Page 4, Line 8(C) According to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy,
Page 4, Line 9"[t]o cut child poverty rates by half, the majority of states would require
Page 4, Line 10a base credit value of between three thousand dollars and four thousand
Page 4, Line 11five hundred dollars per child plus a twenty percent boost for young
Page 4, Line 12children." When coupled with the state and federal earned income tax
Page 4, Line 13credit and the state and federal child tax credit, the additional investment
Page 4, Line 14provided by the family affordability tax credit would establish Colorado
Page 4, Line 15as a national leader in equitable economic policy.
Page 4, Line 16(D) Colorado is dealing with rising costs and funding shortfalls in
Page 4, Line 17many areas across our state, and it is necessary to provide tax credits to
Page 4, Line 18the people who need it most in a way that will do the most good.
Page 4, Line 19Establishing the family affordability tax credit is a proven way to do that;
Page 4, Line 20and
Page 4, Line 21(E) By prioritizing the state's lowest-income families, expanding
Page 4, Line 22the child age eligibility, and including more families, the state can provide
Page 4, Line 23research-backed investments for families. Through thoughtful and
Page 4, Line 24strategic investment, Colorado can cut child poverty nearly in half.
Page 4, Line 25(II) Therefore, it is a priority of Colorado to provide a tax credit
Page 4, Line 26that targets the same taxpayers that the family affordability tax credit
Page 4, Line 27targeted, to offset the reduction in the family affordability tax credit.
Page 5, Line 1(e) (I) This House Bill 26- constitutes a single
Page 5, Line 2comprehensive tax policy change that emphasizes a high-quality, fair tax
Page 5, Line 3system based on principles of horizontal and vertical equity. Horizontal
Page 5, Line 4equity holds that similarly situated taxpayers who engage in the same
Page 5, Line 5activity should be treated equally. Repealing the downloadable software
Page 5, Line 6sales tax exemption promotes horizontal equity by treating the taxation of
Page 5, Line 7all software purchasers the same whether the purchaser downloads the
Page 5, Line 8software or purchases it at a physical retail location. Vertical equity holds
Page 5, Line 9that taxpayers who can pay more in taxes should pay more in taxes.
Page 5, Line 10Creating a tax credit that prioritizes low- and middle-income families
Page 5, Line 11with children reduces the tax burden on the families who can afford to
Page 5, Line 12pay the least in taxes.
Page 5, Line 13(II) The income tax credit created in this House Bill 26-
Page 5, Line 14reduces state tax revenue in an amount equal to or greater than the
Page 5, Line 15amount of state revenue gain attributable to the changes made in this
Page 5, Line 16House Bill 26-;
Page 5, Line 17(III) Any net district revenue gain resulting from the tax policy
Page 5, Line 18change in this House Bill 26- is incidental and de minimis; and
Page 5, Line 19(IV) Therefore, consistent with the Colorado Supreme Court's
Page 5, Line 20holding in TABOR Found. v. Reg'l Transp. Dist., 2018 CO 29, that a tax
Page 5, Line 21policy change that causes either no net district tax revenue gain or a net
Page 5, Line 22district tax revenue gain that is only incidental and de minimis does not
Page 5, Line 23require voter approval under section 20 (4)(a) of article X of the state
Page 5, Line 24constitution, this House Bill 26- is not a tax policy change that
Page 5, Line 25requires voter approval.
Page 5, Line 26SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 39-22-131 as
Page 5, Line 27follows:
Page 6, Line 139-22-131. Family affordability credit - tax preference
Page 6, Line 2performance statement - legislative declaration - definitions.
Page 6, Line 3(1) (a) In accordance with section 39-21-304 (1), which
Page 6, Line 4requires each bill that creates a new tax expenditure to include
Page 6, Line 5a tax preference performance statement as part of a statutory
Page 6, Line 6legislative declaration, the general assembly hereby finds and
Page 6, Line 7declares that the purposes of the income tax credit created in
Page 6, Line 8this section are the same as the family affordability tax credit:
Page 6, Line 9To substantially reduce child poverty, make Colorado more
Page 6, Line 10affordable for families, and help families afford expenses
Page 6, Line 11associated with having children by providing tax relief for
Page 6, Line 12certain individuals.
Page 6, Line 13(b) The general assembly and the state auditor, in
Page 6, Line 14consultation with the department, shall measure the
Page 6, Line 15effectiveness of the income tax credit created in this section in
Page 6, Line 16combination with the family affordability tax credit and, in the
Page 6, Line 17same manner as the general assembly and the state auditor
Page 6, Line 18measure the effectiveness of the family affordability tax credit
Page 6, Line 19by determining the number of Colorado families that, after
Page 6, Line 20claiming a credit pursuant to this section and the family
Page 6, Line 21affordability tax credit, no longer fall below the federal
Page 6, Line 22poverty level in the tax year in which they claimed the credits.
Page 6, Line 23(2) As used in this section, unless the context otherwise
Page 6, Line 24requires:
Page 6, Line 25(a) "Credit" means the credit against income tax created
Page 6, Line 26in this section.
Page 6, Line 27(b) "Department" means the department of revenue.
Page 7, Line 1(c) "Eligible child" means a qualifying child, as defined in
Page 7, Line 2section 152 (c) of the "Internal Revenue Code of 1986"; except
Page 7, Line 3that the age requirements are as set forth in subsections
Page 7, Line 4(3)(a)(I), (3)(a)(II), (3)(b)(I), and (3)(b)(II) of this section.
Page 7, Line 5(d) "Federal poverty level" means the poverty line that
Page 7, Line 6is required to be updated annually within the federal poverty
Page 7, Line 7guidelines adopted by the United States department of health
Page 7, Line 8and human services pursuant to 42 U.S.C. sec. 9902 (2).
Page 7, Line 9(e) "Inflation" means the annual percentage change in the
Page 7, Line 10United States department of labor bureau of labor statistics
Page 7, Line 11consumer price index for Denver-Aurora-Lakewood for all
Page 7, Line 12items paid by all urban consumers, or its applicable successor
Page 7, Line 13index.
Page 7, Line 14(3) (a) In addition to the child tax credit allowed by
Page 7, Line 15section 39-22-129 and, for income tax years commencing on and
Page 7, Line 16after January 1, 2027, but before January 1, 2034, the family
Page 7, Line 17affordability tax credit allowed by section 39-22-130, for
Page 7, Line 18income tax years commencing on or after January 1, 2027, a
Page 7, Line 19resident individual who files a single return is allowed a credit
Page 7, Line 20against the income taxes imposed pursuant to this article 22 for:
Page 7, Line 21(I) Each eligible child of the resident individual who is
Page 7, Line 22five years old or younger at the close of the income tax year in
Page 7, Line 23an amount determined by staff of the legislative council
Page 7, Line 24pursuant to subsection (5)(b) of this section; and
Page 7, Line 25(II) Each eligible child of the resident individual who is six
Page 7, Line 26years old or older but less than seventeen years old at the
Page 7, Line 27close of the income tax year in an amount that is seventy-five
Page 8, Line 1percent of the amount allowed in subsection (3)(a)(I) of this
Page 8, Line 2section.
Page 8, Line 3(b) In addition to the child tax credit allowed by section
Page 8, Line 439-22-129 and, for income tax years commencing on and after
Page 8, Line 5January 1, 2027, but before January 1, 2034, the family
Page 8, Line 6affordability tax credit allowed by section 39-22-130, for
Page 8, Line 7income tax years commencing on or after January 1, 2027, two
Page 8, Line 8resident individuals who file a joint return are allowed a family
Page 8, Line 9affordability tax credit against the income taxes due imposed
Page 8, Line 10pursuant to this article 22 for:
Page 8, Line 11(I) Each eligible child of the resident individual who is
Page 8, Line 12five years old or younger at the close of the income tax year in
Page 8, Line 13an amount determined by staff of the legislative council
Page 8, Line 14pursuant to subsection (5)(b) of this section; and
Page 8, Line 15(II) Each eligible child of the resident individual who is six
Page 8, Line 16years old or older but less than seventeen years old at the
Page 8, Line 17close of the income tax year in an amount that is seventy-five
Page 8, Line 18percent of the amount allowed in subsection (3)(b)(I) of this
Page 8, Line 19section.
Page 8, Line 20(4) (a) Notwithstanding subsection (3) of this section, for
Page 8, Line 21income tax years commencing on or after January 1, 2027, the
Page 8, Line 22credit amounts in:
Page 8, Line 23(I) Subsection (3)(a)(I) of this section are reduced, but not
Page 8, Line 24below zero, by an amount equal to six and eight hundred
Page 8, Line 25seventy-five one-thousandths percent for each five thousand
Page 8, Line 26dollars by which a resident individual's adjusted gross income
Page 8, Line 27exceeds fifteen thousand dollars; and
Page 9, Line 1(II) Subsection (3)(b)(I) of this section are reduced, but not
Page 9, Line 2below zero, by an amount equal to six and eight hundred
Page 9, Line 3seventy-five one-thousandths percent for each five thousand
Page 9, Line 4dollars by which two resident individuals' adjusted gross
Page 9, Line 5income exceeds twenty-five thousand dollars.
Page 9, Line 6(b) For income tax years commencing on or after January
Page 9, Line 71, 2028, the department shall adjust the federal adjusted gross
Page 9, Line 8income amounts set forth in this subsection (4) to reflect
Page 9, Line 9inflation for each income tax year in which the credit described
Page 9, Line 10in this section is allowed if cumulative inflation since the last
Page 9, Line 11adjustment, when applied to the current limits, results in an
Page 9, Line 12increase of at least one thousand dollars when the adjusted
Page 9, Line 13limits are rounded to the nearest one thousand dollars.
Page 9, Line 14(5) Beginning with the quarterly December revenue
Page 9, Line 15forecast that legislative council staff presents in December of
Page 9, Line 162026, and for each December revenue forecast thereafter, as
Page 9, Line 17part of the quarterly December revenue forecast, legislative
Page 9, Line 18council staff shall determine:
Page 9, Line 19(a) For the current calendar year, a projection of the
Page 9, Line 20amount of revenue gain directly attributable to the changes
Page 9, Line 21made in this House Bill 26-, notwithstanding the credit
Page 9, Line 22created in this section;
Page 9, Line 23(b) A dollar amount of the credit available pursuant to
Page 9, Line 24subsections (3)(a)(I) and (3)(b)(I) of this section, which dollar
Page 9, Line 25amount must be the same for both subsections (3)(a)(I) and
Page 9, Line 26(3)(b)(I) of this section, such that the staff of the legislative
Page 9, Line 27council projects, for the current calendar year, that the total
Page 10, Line 1dollar amount of credits claimed pursuant to subsection (3) of
Page 10, Line 2this section will equal the dollar amount that staff of the
Page 10, Line 3legislative council determines pursuant to subsection (5)(a) of
Page 10, Line 4this section.
Page 10, Line 5(6) In the case of a part-year resident, the credit is
Page 10, Line 6apportioned in the ratio determined under section 39-22-110 (1).
Page 10, Line 7(7) The credit is not considered to be income or resources
Page 10, Line 8for the purpose of determining eligibility for the payment of
Page 10, Line 9public assistance benefits and medical assistance benefits
Page 10, Line 10authorized under state law or for a payment made under any
Page 10, Line 11other publicly funded program.
Page 10, Line 12(8) The amount of the credit that exceeds the resident
Page 10, Line 13individual's income taxes due is refunded to the individual.
Page 10, Line 14(9) The department is authorized and encouraged to
Page 10, Line 15develop a means of refunding the credits to resident individuals
Page 10, Line 16who qualify for the credits in twelve equal monthly refunds
Page 10, Line 17rather than annually.
Page 10, Line 18(10) Notwithstanding section 39-21-304 (4), the credit does
Page 10, Line 19not repeal after a specified period of tax years.
Page 10, Line 20SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 39-26-102, amend
Page 10, Line 21(5.7) and (15)(c) as follows:
Page 10, Line 2239-26-102. Definitions - repeal.
Page 10, Line 23As used in this article 26, unless the context otherwise requires:
Page 10, Line 24(5.7) "Mainframe computer access" means the provision of access
Page 10, Line 25to computer equipment for the purpose of storing or processing data.
Page 10, Line 26"Mainframe computer access" does not include the provision of access to
Page 10, Line 27computer equipment for the purpose of examining or acquiring data
Page 11, Line 1maintained by the vendor.
"Mainframe computer access" does not includePage 11, Line 2
the provision of access to computer equipment incident to electronicPage 11, Line 3
computer software delivery, as defined in subsection (15)(c)(II)(C) of thisPage 11, Line 4
section, or incident to the use of computer software hosted by anPage 11, Line 5
application service provider, as defined in subsection (15)(c)(II)(A) ofPage 11, Line 6
this section.Page 11, Line 7(15) (c) (I) "Tangible personal property"
commencing July 1,Page 11, Line 8
2012, shall include includes computer software.if the computerPage 11, Line 9
software meets all of the following criteria:Page 11, Line 10
(A) The computer software is prepackaged for repeated sale orPage 11, Line 11
license;Page 11, Line 12
(B) The use of the computer software is governed by a tear-openPage 11, Line 13
nonnegotiable license agreement; andPage 11, Line 14
(C) The computer software is delivered to the customer in aPage 11, Line 15
tangible medium. Computer software is not delivered to the customer inPage 11, Line 16
a tangible medium if it is provided through an application servicePage 11, Line 17
provider, delivered by electronic computer software delivery, orPage 11, Line 18
transferred by load and leave computer software delivery.Page 11, Line 19(II) As used in this
paragraph (c) subsection (15)(c), unless thePage 11, Line 20context otherwise requires:
Page 11, Line 21(A)
"Application service provider" or "ASP" means an entity thatPage 11, Line 22
retains custody over or hosts computer software for use by third parties.Page 11, Line 23
Users of the computer software hosted by an ASP typically will access thePage 11, Line 24
computer software via the internet. The ASP may or may not own orPage 11, Line 25
license the computer software, but generally will own and maintainPage 11, Line 26
hardware and networking equipment required for the user to access thePage 11, Line 27
computer software. Where the ASP owns the computer software, the ASPPage 12, Line 1
may charge the user a license fee for the computer software or a fee forPage 12, Line 2
maintaining the computer software or hardware used by its customer.Page 12, Line 3(B) "Computer software" means a set of coded instructions that
Page 12, Line 4are both designed to cause a computer or
automatic data processingPage 12, Line 5
equipment to perform a task other electronic device to perform aPage 12, Line 6task and are delivered by any means, including compact disc,
Page 12, Line 7download, or remote access through the internet. "Computer
Page 12, Line 8software" includes applications installed on cellular phones,
Page 12, Line 9tablets, or other mobile devices.
Page 12, Line 10(C)
"Electronic computer software delivery" means computerPage 12, Line 11
software transferred by remote telecommunications to the purchaser'sPage 12, Line 12
computer, where the purchaser does not obtain possession of any tangiblePage 12, Line 13
medium in the transaction.Page 12, Line 14(D)
"Load and leave computer software delivery" means deliveryPage 12, Line 15
of computer software to the purchaser by use of a tangible medium wherePage 12, Line 16
the title to or possession of the tangible medium is not transferred to thePage 12, Line 17
purchaser, and where the computer software is manually loaded by thePage 12, Line 18
vendor, or the vendor's representative, at the purchaser's location.Page 12, Line 19(E)
"Prepackaged for repeated sale or license" means computerPage 12, Line 20
software that is prepackaged for repeated sale or license in the same formPage 12, Line 21
to multiple users without modification, and is typically sold in aPage 12, Line 22
shrink-wrapped box.Page 12, Line 23(F)
"Tangible medium" means a tape, disk, compact disc, card, orPage 12, Line 24
comparable physical medium.Page 12, Line 25(G)
"Tear-open nonnegotiable license agreement" means a licensePage 12, Line 26
agreement contained on or in the package, which by its terms becomesPage 12, Line 27
effective upon opening of the package and accepting the licensingPage 13, Line 1
agreement. "Tear-open nonnegotiable license agreement" does notPage 13, Line 2
include a written license agreement or contract signed by the licensor andPage 13, Line 3
the licensee.Page 13, Line 4(III)
The internalized instruction code that controls the basicPage 13, Line 5
operations, such as arithmetic and logic, of the computer causing it toPage 13, Line 6
execute instructions contained in system programs is an integral part ofPage 13, Line 7
the computer and is not normally accessible or modifiable by the user.Page 13, Line 8
Such internalized instruction code is considered part of the hardware andPage 13, Line 9
considered tangible personal property that is taxable pursuant to sectionPage 13, Line 10
39-26-104 (1)(a). The fact that the vendor does or does not chargePage 13, Line 11
separately for such code is immaterial.Page 13, Line 12(IV)
If a retailer sells computer software to a Colorado purchaserPage 13, Line 13
that is considered tangible personal property taxable pursuant to sectionPage 13, Line 14
39-26-104 (1)(a) and the Colorado purchaser pays the retailer for aPage 13, Line 15
quantity of computer software licenses with the intent to distribute thePage 13, Line 16
computer software to any of the purchaser's locations outside ofPage 13, Line 17
Colorado, the measure of Colorado sales tax due is the total of the licensePage 13, Line 18
fees associated only with the licenses that are actually used in Colorado.Page 13, Line 19
The Colorado purchaser shall provide a written statement to the retailer,Page 13, Line 20
attesting to the amount of the license fees associated with Colorado andPage 13, Line 21
with points outside of Colorado. The written statement shall relieve thePage 13, Line 22
retailer of any liability associated with the proration.Page 13, Line 23SECTION 4. In Colorado Revised Statutes, 39-26-713, add (3)
Page 13, Line 24as follows:
Page 13, Line 2539-26-713. Tangible personal property.
Page 13, Line 26(3) The sale, storage, use, or consumption of computer
Page 13, Line 27software, as defined in section 39-26-102 (15)(c)(II)(B), is exempt
Page 14, Line 1from taxation under the provisions of parts 1 and 2 of this
Page 14, Line 2article 26 if that sale, storage, use, or consumption of computer
Page 14, Line 3software is:
Page 14, Line 4(a) Governed by a negotiable license agreement; or
Page 14, Line 5(b) Developed for use by a particular user.
Page 14, Line 6SECTION 5. Effective date - applicability. This act takes effect
Page 14, Line 7on passage, except sections 3 and 4 are effective January 1, 2027, and
Page 14, Line 8apply to the sale, storage, use, and consumption of tangible personal
Page 14, Line 9property on and after January 1, 2027.
Page 14, Line 10SECTION 6. Safety clause. The general assembly finds,
Page 14, Line 11determines, and declares that this act is necessary for the immediate
Page 14, Line 12preservation of the public peace, health, or safety or for appropriations for
Page 14, Line 13the support and maintenance of the departments of the state and state
Page 14, Line 14institutions.