A Bill for an Act
Page 1, Line 101Concerning measures to reduce emissions from certain
Page 1, Line 102electric generating units in the state.
Bill Summary
(Note: This summary applies to this bill as introduced and does not reflect any amendments that may be subsequently adopted. If this bill passes third reading in the house of introduction, a bill summary that applies to the reengrossed version of this bill will be available at http://leg.colorado.gov.)
Section 2 of the bill requires the air quality control commission, no later than December 31, 2029, to adopt a final rule (rule) establishing certain limits on the emission of nitrogen oxides and sulfur dioxide from an electric generating unit (unit) that is owned or operated by an electric utility, is located in the state, and emitted 200 tons or more of nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxide, or both in calendar year 2024 (covered electric generating unit). The rule must require compliance with the emission limits as soon as practicable after December 31, 2030, and must not cover units that have ceased operations, burn natural gas or fuel oil only, or have certain systems installed before December 31, 2029. The owner or operator of a covered electric generating unit is required to provide quarterly emission reports showing compliance with the rule to the division of administration in the department of public health and environment (division).
Section 3 requires an investor-owned utility or wholesale electric cooperative that is the owner or operator of a unit, beginning 150 days after the issuance of a federal order requiring the unit to remain operating after the unit was scheduled to retire (order) and continuing every 90 days until the order is no longer in effect, to file a report with the public utilities commission (commission) that contains certain information about the costs to operate the unit and the amount of electricity generated by the unit. The commission must make these reports publicly available.
Section 3 also allows an investor-owned utility to submit an application for a financing order to recover the costs of complying with an order.
Section 3 also requires that, if the commission issues a written decision approving a portfolio that consists of supply-side resources for an investor-owned utility serving more than 500,000 customers, the commission must approve a total amount of accredited capacity for the investor-owned utility to reliably implement certain retirement dates or operational restrictions applicable to the investor-owned utility's covered electric generating unit and comply with any applicable carbon dioxide emission reduction requirements. This accredited capacity requirement applies to an investor-owned utility serving more than 500,000 customers until the division determines that the investor-owned utility has achieved certain carbon dioxide emission reductions or until the investor-owned utility has retired all covered electric generating units, whichever is later.
Page 2, Line 1Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Colorado:
Page 2, Line 2SECTION 1. Legislative declaration. (1) The general assembly
Page 2, Line 3finds that:
Page 2, Line 4(a) The federal government has taken a series of actions to
Page 2, Line 5override the choices that Colorado electric utilities and state agencies
Page 2, Line 6have made;
Page 2, Line 7(b) For example, the federal government has ordered a power
Page 3, Line 1plant to remain available past the closure date that 3 Colorado utilities had
Page 3, Line 2decided was in the best interest of their customers;
Page 3, Line 3(c) Federal actions threaten to raise electricity costs for consumers
Page 3, Line 4by requiring utilities to undertake costly repairs for old plants that were
Page 3, Line 5scheduled to close, by potentially crowding out cheaper replacement
Page 3, Line 6resources, and by forcing customers to pay for the replacement resources
Page 3, Line 7and then pay again to keep the plant online that was intended to close;
Page 3, Line 8(d) The general assembly has previously authorized the use of a
Page 3, Line 9low-cost financing tool, securitization, for certain costs, and it is desirable
Page 3, Line 10to allow the use of this tool for costs to comply with a federal order;
Page 3, Line 11(e) Federal actions also risk increasing air pollution;
Page 3, Line 12(f) In addition, certain power plants in Colorado were constructed
Page 3, Line 13several decades ago and have not installed the most modern, effective
Page 3, Line 14pollution controls that more recently built power plants have installed;
Page 3, Line 15(g) Electric power plants are the largest stationary sources of air
Page 3, Line 16pollution from nitrogen oxides and sulfur dioxide in the state;
Page 3, Line 17(h) Certain power plants in the state are currently scheduled to
Page 3, Line 18close by the end of 2029;
Page 3, Line 19(i) In addition, the general assembly has required that a qualifying
Page 3, Line 20retail utility reduce its carbon dioxide emissions 80% by 2030 relative to
Page 3, Line 212005 levels;
Page 3, Line 22(j) The qualifying retail utility has also planned to replace certain
Page 3, Line 23older power plants in order to reduce customer costs; and
Page 3, Line 24(k) Resource adequacy and reliability are of paramount
Page 3, Line 25importance.
Page 3, Line 26(2) The general assembly therefore declares that:
Page 3, Line 27(a) If certain power plants operate past their currently scheduled
Page 4, Line 1retirement dates and into the 2030s, it is appropriate to require that these
Page 4, Line 2older plants be modernized to install the most effective pollution controls
Page 4, Line 3that are currently available;
Page 4, Line 4(b) In order to understand the cost and environmental impacts of
Page 4, Line 5certain federal orders, investor-owned utilities and wholesale electric
Page 4, Line 6cooperatives should be required to report on how compliance with certain
Page 4, Line 7federal orders will affect Colorado's ratepayers and environment; and
Page 4, Line 8(c) The public utilities commission should approve enough
Page 4, Line 9resources for a qualifying retail utility to reliably implement its approved
Page 4, Line 10plans to replace older power plants and to meet the 2030 clean energy
Page 4, Line 11target the general assembly has adopted.
Page 4, Line 12SECTION 2. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 25-7-148 as
Page 4, Line 13follows:
Page 4, Line 1425-7-148. Nitrogen oxides and sulfur dioxide emission limits
Page 4, Line 15for covered electric generating units after 2030 - rules - quarterly
Page 4, Line 16reports - definitions.
Page 4, Line 17(1) As used in this section, unless the context otherwise
Page 4, Line 18requires:
Page 4, Line 19(a) (I) "Covered electric generating unit" or "unit" means
Page 4, Line 20an electric generating unit that is owned or operated by an
Page 4, Line 21electric utility; that is located in the state; and that, in
Page 4, Line 22calendar year 2024, emitted two hundred tons or more of
Page 4, Line 23nitrogen oxides, two hundred tons or more of sulfur dioxide, or
Page 4, Line 24both.
Page 4, Line 25(II) "Covered electric generating unit" or "unit" does not
Page 4, Line 26include an electric generating unit that:
Page 4, Line 27(A) Burns natural gas or fuel oil only; or
Page 5, Line 1(B) Has both a flue gas desulfurization system and a
Page 5, Line 2selective catalytic reduction system installed.
Page 5, Line 3(b) "Final rule" means the final rule adopted by the
Page 5, Line 4commission pursuant to subsection (2)(a) of this section.
Page 5, Line 5(2) (a) No later than December 31, 2029, the commission
Page 5, Line 6shall adopt a final rule establishing limits on the emission of
Page 5, Line 7nitrogen oxides and sulfur dioxide from each covered electric
Page 5, Line 8generating unit; except that the commission shall not establish
Page 5, Line 9emission limits for a covered electric generating unit that,
Page 5, Line 10before December 31, 2029, has ceased operations, converts to
Page 5, Line 11burn natural gas or fuel oil only, or has both a flue gas
Page 5, Line 12desulfurization system and a selective catalytic reduction
Page 5, Line 13system installed.
Page 5, Line 14(b) For each unit, the limit on the emission of nitrogen
Page 5, Line 15oxides in the final rule must be based upon, and reflective of,
Page 5, Line 16operation of a selective catalytic reduction system at the unit.
Page 5, Line 17(c) For each unit, the limit on the emission of sulfur
Page 5, Line 18dioxide in the final rule must be based upon, and reflective of,
Page 5, Line 19operation of either a flue gas desulfurization system or a dry
Page 5, Line 20spray absorber at the unit.
Page 5, Line 21(d) For each unit, the commission shall require compliance
Page 5, Line 22with the emission limits required by the final rule on and after
Page 5, Line 23a date that the commission determines is practicable, which date
Page 5, Line 24must be after December 31, 2030.
Page 5, Line 25(e) A covered electric generating unit that converts to
Page 5, Line 26burn natural gas or fuel oil only is not subject to the emission
Page 5, Line 27limits in the final rule.
Page 6, Line 1(3) The owner or operator of a covered electric
Page 6, Line 2generating unit shall provide quarterly emission reports to the
Page 6, Line 3division demonstrating compliance with the final rule.
Page 6, Line 4(4) (a) In an electric resource plan filed with the public
Page 6, Line 5utilities commission in which a utility evaluates the operation of
Page 6, Line 6a covered electric generating unit after December 31, 2030, the
Page 6, Line 7utility shall include an estimate of the costs to comply with this
Page 6, Line 8section.
Page 6, Line 9(b) A utility that does not file an electric resource plan
Page 6, Line 10with the public utilities commission is encouraged to include an
Page 6, Line 11estimate of the costs to comply with this section in an
Page 6, Line 12evaluation of the operation of a covered electric generating
Page 6, Line 13unit after December 31, 2030, and to make the estimate publicly
Page 6, Line 14available.
Page 6, Line 15SECTION 3. In Colorado Revised Statutes, add 40-2-140 and
Page 6, Line 1640-2-141 as follows:
Page 6, Line 1740-2-140. Requirements for electric generating units subject
Page 6, Line 18to a federal order - reporting - cost recovery - applicability -
Page 6, Line 19definitions.
Page 6, Line 20(1) As used in this section, unless the context otherwise
Page 6, Line 21requires:
Page 6, Line 22(a) "Order" means an order that:
Page 6, Line 23(I) Is issued by the president of the United States, a
Page 6, Line 24representative of the federal government, or a federal agency;
Page 6, Line 25and
Page 6, Line 26(II) Requires a unit to remain available or connected to
Page 6, Line 27the electric grid to transmit or generate electricity after the
Page 7, Line 1date that the unit was scheduled to retire in accordance with
Page 7, Line 2an electric resource plan approved by the commission or the
Page 7, Line 3utility's governing entity prior to the issuance of the order.
Page 7, Line 4(b) "Unit" means an electric generating unit in the state.
Page 7, Line 5(c) "Wholesale electric cooperative" has the meaning set
Page 7, Line 6forth in section 40-2-134 (2).
Page 7, Line 7(2) (a) (I) Beginning one hundred fifty days after the
Page 7, Line 8issuance of an order or one hundred fifty days after the
Page 7, Line 9effective date of this section, whichever is later, and continuing
Page 7, Line 10every ninety days until the order is no longer in effect, an
Page 7, Line 11investor-owned utility or a wholesale electric cooperative that
Page 7, Line 12is the owner or operator of a unit subject to the order shall file
Page 7, Line 13a report with the commission in the docket of the
Page 7, Line 14investor-owned utility's or wholesale electric cooperative's
Page 7, Line 15pending or most recent electric resource plan, which report
Page 7, Line 16must contain the following information, to the extent the
Page 7, Line 17information is available:
Page 7, Line 18(A) The total operations and maintenance expenses
Page 7, Line 19required to keep the unit available or to operate the unit during
Page 7, Line 20the preceding ninety days;
Page 7, Line 21(B) The total capital expenditures incurred to keep the
Page 7, Line 22unit available or operate the unit during the preceding ninety
Page 7, Line 23days;
Page 7, Line 24(C) The total number of hours that the unit generated
Page 7, Line 25electricity during the preceding ninety days;
Page 7, Line 26(D) The electrical output of the unit during the preceding
Page 7, Line 27ninety days; and
Page 8, Line 1(E) Any curtailment of resources caused by the order and
Page 8, Line 2the incremental cost of the curtailment.
Page 8, Line 3(II) An investor-owned utility or a wholesale electric
Page 8, Line 4cooperative may comply with subsection (2)(a)(I) of this section
Page 8, Line 5by submitting information to the commission that the operator
Page 8, Line 6files with a federal agency if the information addresses the
Page 8, Line 7topics required by subsection (2)(a)(I) of this section.
Page 8, Line 8(III) If an investor-owned utility is an owner, but not the
Page 8, Line 9operator, of a unit subject to an order, the investor-owned
Page 8, Line 10utility shall file reports with the commission, according to the
Page 8, Line 11schedule specified by subsection (2)(a)(I) of this section,
Page 8, Line 12disclosing the investor-owned utility's share of the total costs
Page 8, Line 13specified in subsections (2)(a)(I)(A) and (2)(a)(I)(B) of this section.
Page 8, Line 14(b) (I) Except as set forth in subsection (2)(b)(II) of this
Page 8, Line 15section, the commission shall make information provided
Page 8, Line 16pursuant to subsection (2)(a) of this section publicly available.
Page 8, Line 17(II) If an investor-owned utility or wholesale electric
Page 8, Line 18cooperative designates information provided pursuant to
Page 8, Line 19subsection (2)(a) of this section as confidential, the commission
Page 8, Line 20shall make that information available only to a person that has
Page 8, Line 21signed and filed with the commission the appropriate
Page 8, Line 22nondisclosure agreement required by commission rules.
Page 8, Line 23(3) An investor-owned utility may submit an application
Page 8, Line 24for a financing order pursuant to section 40-41-103 to recover
Page 8, Line 25the costs of complying with an order, either as a standalone
Page 8, Line 26application or as part of a broader financing order application
Page 8, Line 27that the investor-owned utility chooses to submit pursuant to
Page 9, Line 1section 40-41-103.
Page 9, Line 2(4) Notwithstanding any provision of this section to the
Page 9, Line 3contrary, this section applies only:
Page 9, Line 4(a) To the owner or operator of a unit that is subject to an
Page 9, Line 5order and that is required to file an electric resource plan with
Page 9, Line 6the commission;
Page 9, Line 7(b) During the time period that an order is in effect; and
Page 9, Line 8(c) To the extent not inconsistent with an order.
Page 9, Line 940-2-141. Requirements for commission review of portfolio
Page 9, Line 10consisting of supply-side resources - applicability - definition.
Page 9, Line 11(1) As used in this section, unless the context otherwise
Page 9, Line 12requires, "covered electric generating unit" has the meaning set
Page 9, Line 13forth in section 25-7-148 (1)(a).
Page 9, Line 14(2) If the commission issues a written decision approving a
Page 9, Line 15portfolio that consists in whole or in part of supply-side
Page 9, Line 16resources for an investor-owned utility serving more than five
Page 9, Line 17hundred thousand customers, the commission shall approve a
Page 9, Line 18total amount of accredited capacity, which can come from any
Page 9, Line 19mix of supply-side or demand-side resources, that is sufficient
Page 9, Line 20for the investor-owned utility to reliably:
Page 9, Line 21(a) Implement the retirement dates or operational
Page 9, Line 22restrictions in effect at the time of the commission's decision
Page 9, Line 23regarding a covered electric generating unit owned or operated
Page 9, Line 24by the investor-owned utility; and
Page 9, Line 25(b) Comply with any applicable state law requirements to
Page 9, Line 26achieve carbon dioxide emission reductions, including the
Page 9, Line 27requirements described in section 40-2-125.5.
Page 10, Line 1(3) The commission shall certify in writing in the written
Page 10, Line 2decision approving the portfolio that the portfolio meets the
Page 10, Line 3accredited capacity requirements described in subsection (2) of
Page 10, Line 4this section.
Page 10, Line 5(4) Nothing in this section shall be construed to alter the
Page 10, Line 6commission's authority or obligation, in statute or in rule as of
Page 10, Line 7the effective date of this section, to consider factors in the
Page 10, Line 8approval of a portfolio, including cost and rate impacts, if the
Page 10, Line 9portfolio the commission approves complies with the accredited
Page 10, Line 10capacity requirements described in subsection (2) of this section.
Page 10, Line 11(5) This section applies to an investor-owned utility
Page 10, Line 12serving more than five hundred thousand customers until the
Page 10, Line 13division of administration in the department of public health and
Page 10, Line 14environment determines that the investor-owned utility has
Page 10, Line 15achieved the carbon dioxide emission reductions described in
Page 10, Line 16section 40-2-125.5 (4)(c) or until the investor-owned utility has
Page 10, Line 17retired each covered electric generating unit owned or
Page 10, Line 18operated by the investor-owned utility, whichever is later.
Page 10, Line 19SECTION 4. Severability. If any provision of this act or the
Page 10, Line 20application of this act to any person or circumstance is held invalid, the
Page 10, Line 21invalidity does not affect other provisions or applications of the act that
Page 10, Line 22can be given effect without the invalid provision or application, and to
Page 10, Line 23this end the provisions of this act are declared to be severable.
Page 10, Line 24SECTION 5. Applicability. This act applies to conduct occurring
Page 10, Line 25on or after the effective date of this act.
Page 10, Line 26SECTION 6. Safety clause. The general assembly finds,
Page 10, Line 27determines, and declares that this act is necessary for the immediate
Page 11, Line 1preservation of the public peace, health, or safety or for appropriations for
Page 11, Line 2the support and maintenance of the departments of the state and state
Page 11, Line 3institutions.